Module 1.2: Data Quality - Standards

In this lab, I explored the concept of data accuracy standards by determined the positional accuracy of road networks. The two sets of road networks were for the city of Albuquerque, New Mexico. One was a shapefile of road center lines from the city of Albuquerque itself and the other was a shapefile with streets from StreetMap USA, a TeleAtlas product distributed by ESRI with ArcGIS software.

According to National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy (NSSDA) guidelines, at least 20 reference points within the study area are needed to test the accuracy of each of the road networks. Additionally, no fewer than 20% of the reference points should be located in each quadrant and the distance between each of the points should be at least 10% of the diagonal distance across the study area. Following the NSSDA guidelines, I divided the study area into 4 quadrants measured the diagonal distance of each quadrant to use in my intersection selection process.

To select the reference points, I zoomed into intersections with the ortho imagery turned on. I selected intersections within each quadrant that occurred in both road networks and had a  easily identifiable intersection point. A total of 5 points were digitized in each quadrant and I used the Measure tool to ensure that the points were within the guideline distance. Below are the reference points selected for accuracy testing:


Once the reference points were digitized, a unique ID was added to each of the shapefiles so that the reference points could be tested against the same intersection points in each of the road networks. I used the XY Coordinate tool to add XY coordinates to each of the shapefiles. This data was entered into the accuracy statistic worksheet. The worksheet determines the error between each point and the reference, the root mean square error (RMSE) and the NSSDA number. The NSSDA number is the 95% confidence level which is determined by multiplying the RMSE by 1.7308 (the standard error of the mean).

My positional accuracy results for each of the data sets written as formal statements conforming with the NSSDA guidelines which would also be incorporated into metadata are as follows:

ABQ Streets City Data: Using the National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy, the data set tested 21.531 feet horizontal accuracy at 95% confidence level.


Street Map USA: Using the National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy, the data set tested 254.566 feet horizontal accuracy at 95% confidence level.

From these results, we can conclude that the ABQ Streets City Data was much more accurate than the Street Map USA data. This makes sense considering that the Street Map USA data is a nationwide dataset, whereas the  ABQ Streets City data is a local data set. We could better assess the accuracy of the data sets by using more reference points as well as using a GPS to truly ground truth the intersections. Positional accuracy is an important, necessary piece of information when considering the use of geospatial data and should be incorporated into metadata.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Module 2: Coordinate Systems

Image
In this week's lab I explore different coordinate systems and projections in order to better understand the nature of distortions introduced by the systems. For the last part of the lab, I was tasked with selecting a state in the contiguous US and selecting an appropriate projection for the area. I selected the state of Wyoming as my area of interest. Wyoming has 4 State Plane zones and two UTM zones, so neither a single State Plane nor UTM system would work for this area without distorting the size or shape of the state. Therefore, the best coordinate system for this area is Custom Coordinate system. I chose NAD 1983 WyLam (Meters), a custom system specifically for the state of Wyoming, as the projected coordinate system. This coordinate system is a Lambert secant-case normal-aspect conic type projection which preserves shape and is appropriate for a general reference map. The standard parallels are placed at 41N and 45N, the boundaries of the state of Wyoming, which minimizes...
Read more

Module 6: Proportional Symbol and Bivariate Choropleth Mapping

Image
The objectives of this week's lab was to explore proportional symbol and bivariate choropleth mapping techniques, as well as customizing legends for each technique. One of the data sets for this lab included positive and negative values. The final map utilizes proportional symbols to show both positive and negative values. This map is essentially two proportional symbol maps overlaid on each other, one for positive job growth and another for negative job growth, with the symbols for both variables sized the same. Utilizing proportional symbols to show both positive and negative values is an effective way to visualize areas that show the greatest and lowest values. These areas are easy to see quickly on the map and give the map reader a simple way to visualize the variable being mapped. Fig 1. Proportional symbol map using positive and negative values.  Another data set for this lab examined contained two data variables: percent of the US population in each state that is obe...
Read more

Module 7: Choropleth and Proportional Symbol Mapping

Image
The purpose of this lab was to explore choropleth mapping and utilize proportional symbology for two different data sets. The resulting map shows population density and wine consumption in European countries. To create this map, I used ArcMap with finishing in Adobe Illustrator. I explored the use of images instead of circles to symbolize wine consumption, however, after trying many options, I felt the image made the data harder to interpret. Instead, I elected to use proportional circles to symbolize wine consumption because they are more easily interpreted. I used proportional symbology over graduated symbology because the proportional symbology could be employed without classifying the data and the size of the symbols makes the data easy to interpret quickly. The most difficult part of creating this map was labeling all the countries. In order to better view a portion of the map that is cluttered with both small countries and many circles, I created an inset map. The inset map ma...
Read more